HOW IT STARTED
Every great swim has a story. Ours began with one man's determination to protect an iconic piece of Florida Keys history and grew into an open water swimming tradition that brings athletes, volunteers, and the Islamorada community together year after year.
One Man. One Big Idea.
Long before Swim for Alligator Lighthouse became an annual tradition, there was Lighthouse Larry.
Concerned about the historic Alligator Reef Lighthouse's deteriorating condition, Larry Herlth set out to draw attention to its preservation. He took his message beyond the shoreline, swimming from Islamorada to the lighthouse and back to raise awareness and encourage government officials to recognize the importance of protecting this Florida Keys landmark. His determination helped spark an idea that would eventually bring an entire community together around the lighthouse.
The First Swim: 2013
On September 21, 2013, X adventurous swimmers took on the inaugural Swim for Alligator Lighthouse, turning Larry's vision into an official event. Led by the local Fighting Manatees swim community, the first swim brought together athletes, organizers and supporters who believed this extraordinary stretch of ocean deserved to be shared.
Early faces of the event included Rob Dixon, Mike Walsh, and Craig Travers, each part of the community that helped shape its beginnings. What started as a grassroots challenge quickly became something more: a celebration of open water swimming, the Florida Keys and the people who make both so special.
From a Small Swim to a Keys Tradition
Over the years, Swim for Alligator Lighthouse has grown from a grassroots challenge into a beloved open water swimming tradition, welcoming solo swimmers and relay teams from around the world. But the heart of the event has never changed.
Its success has been shaped by the generosity of local Islamorada businesses, dedicated volunteers, longtime team members and an incredible open water swimming community. From the people who have supported the event since its earliest days to the athletes who return year after year, each has helped build something special.
Today, the swim is about more than reaching the lighthouse. It's about the people, the place and the shared experience that keeps everyone coming back.